I hear advice from the older generation that “buying a house is an investment”. On one level, I get that. Buying a house is a...
I hear advice from the older generation that “buying a house is an investment”.
On one level, I get that. Buying a house is a better way to spend money than renting, because at the end, you have something. You have a whole frigging house.
On another level, I think that the idea that home prices should outpace inflation is insane and maybe has broken modern society.-Andre Cooper, Maybe Treating Housing as an Investment was a Colossal, Society-Shattering Mistake
This entire article is “a-HYUK, why would we expect homes to appreciate when the building’s obviously a depreciating asset? We’ve simply stumbled down a nonsense path that I just realized because I r so smart!”
Because even as the structure depreciates the property claim on the underlying land appreciates because it’s a finite good facing rising demand, dipshit.
This points at the question they really haven’t had to confront since the legal form was established in the 1970s: what are condominiums for?
…they’re for living in?
Are you asking why it is legal to purchase only a partial ownership in land/building, or are you asking why anybody would want to do that?
Well I suppose in the sense of condo towers, like anything built in 1981 Miami or Manhattan seemed like already the maximum units you could put on that site so it didn’t matter if all you ever had was the title to one with no provision for anything else
But like, if you can’t sell the option to redevelop the property what do you have beyond the one we’ve-only-seen-sub-40yo-of-these-buildings-in-America-and-remember-that-one-that-collapsed-in-Florida?
I guess your transferable title gives you one vote towards a condo board that could dispose of the whole property for redevelopment.
Well the reason I bought a condo unit was because I wanted to buy, not rent[1], I wanted to live in the center of town and didn’t (and don’t) have the casual millions necessary to own a house in the center of town.
[1] And the buy-not-rent idea does make sense: My current condo is better than my old apartment, financing costs me less than rent used to, and of course it is me rather than my landlord that gains the accumulating home equity)
Well if we’re disclosing our personal investments here mine is kinda that my childhood cul-de-sac home was a condominium, built in the late ‘70s before it was clear that was not the proper form for subdivisions, and the city is actually densifying out to it now (this was for a while “average, good people” houses being bought and inhabited, maybe un-duplexed, maybe torn down and rebuilt to lot lines by rich people. who were often sympathetic greyhairs.)
And I am going to inherit that house in the next 20 years, and have to take that seriously, and also am displacing here some emotional intensity I think I’m supposed to feel about that but can’t now, now that I can’t feel loss I’m not sure how I’m going to process my parents’ inevitable upcoming death and it fucks with me.

